THREE DISCOVERY OPINIONS OUT OF THE MIDDLE DISTRICT: (1) PLAINTIFFS CAN DEPOSE EXPERT USED TO INVESTIGATE CLAIM, NOT HIRED IN ANTICIPATION OF LITIGATION; (2) PLAINTIFFS CAN DEPOSE POLICE INVESTIGATOR; (3) PLAINTIFFS CAN DEPOSE UNDERWRITER WHO MAY HAVE HAD A ROLE IN CLAIM HANDLING (Middle District)

Middle District Magistrate Judge Joseph F. Saporito, Jr. recently issued three discovery opinions arising out of a first party fire property damage case. The insureds…

INSURER NOT REQUIRED TO PRODUCE PERSONNEL FILE, BUT IS REQUIRED TO (1) PROVIDE CORPORATE DESIGNEE FOR DEPOSITION, (2) PRODUCE MANUALS AND TRAINING MATERIALS WITHIN CERTAIN TIME/GEOGRAPHIC LIMITS, AND (3) PROVIDE CLAIMS FILES TO THE COURT FOR IN CAMERA REVIEW ON PRIVILEGE AND WORK PRODUCT (Philadelphia Federal)

The instant dispute involves the depositions of the claims handler and a corporate designee, as well as the scope of document discovery. The insurer made…